Follow us

Best Kitchen Forge

Knives and sharpeners, explained

Best Knife Sharpener: How to Pick for Your Knives

Updated

A knife sharpener block and a kitchen knife on a wooden cutting board beside a small bowl
Affiliate disclosure: as an Amazon Associate, Best Kitchen Forge earns from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.
QUICK ANSWERThe best knife sharpener is the one that suits your knives and your patience. A guided system is the easiest to repeat, an electric model is the fastest, and a whetstone gives the most control once you have practised.
Key takeaways
  • Match the sharpener to the kind of steel and the angle of your knives.
  • A guide holds the angle for you, which matters more than speed for a beginner.
  • Read the maker’s page for which knives the sharpener is made for, and which it is not.
HOW WE CHOSEWe read each maker’s own product page and instructions, then compare what they say side by side. Where we have not used a product ourselves, we say so.

Start With Your Knives

Before you look at sharpeners, look at your knives. Most Western kitchen knives are sharpened at a wider angle than most Japanese knives, and a sharpener built for one can be the wrong choice for the other. Check the maker’s page for the recommended angle and steel type.

A knife sharpener block and a kitchen knife on a wooden cutting board beside a small bowl
Sample image for the design review.

Compare the Three Main Types

Most home sharpeners fall into one of three groups. Here is how they differ in the ways that matter in a home kitchen.

TypeBest forLearning curveWatch out for
Guided systemBeginners who want a repeatable angleLowSetup takes a few minutes
Electric sharpenerQuick touch-ups on everyday knivesVery lowSome remove more steel than needed
WhetstonePeople who enjoy the craft and want controlHighNeeds practice and a flat stone

Three Example Sharpeners

These example cards show how each product will appear in a real guide: a short reason to choose it, what we like and what to watch for.

Example guided sharpening system
EASIEST TO REPEAT

Example guided sharpening system

Adjustable angleClamp holds the knifeFine and coarse stones

Check it on Amazon →

Choose this if you want the same angle every time without having to hold it by hand. The clamp keeps the knife still while you work.

WHAT WE LIKEHolds the angle for you · Works on many knife types · Easy to learn
WATCH OUT FORTakes a few minutes to set up · Takes more bench space than a pull-through
Example electric knife sharpener
FASTEST

Example electric sharpener

Built-in angle guidesSeveral stagesQuick to use

Check it on Amazon →

Choose this if you want a sharper knife in a minute and don’t want to learn a new skill. Pull the knife through the guides and it does the rest.

WHAT WE LIKEVery quick · Little skill needed · Good for everyday knives
WATCH OUT FORCan remove more steel than you need · Check it suits your knife’s angle
Example two-sided whetstone
MOST CONTROL

Example two-sided whetstone

Coarse and fine sidesNon-slip baseSoak before use

Check it on Amazon →

Choose this if you enjoy learning a craft and want full control over the edge. It takes practice but rewards patience.

WHAT WE LIKEFull control of the angle · Works on any knife · Lasts for years
WATCH OUT FORTakes practice to get an even edge · Needs flattening over time

Real-World Checks Before You Buy

  • Check the angle. Find the angle your knives are meant to have and make sure the sharpener can match it.
  • Check the steel. Very hard steels need the right abrasive. The maker’s page should say what the sharpener can handle.
  • Count the steps. If the setup puts you off, you will not use it. Pick the one you will actually reach for.

Skip it if your knives are serrated or very cheap. Test a pull-through on one old knife first.

How to Keep Your Edge Between Sharpenings

  • Use a wooden or plastic cutting board, never glass or stone.
  • Hand-wash and dry your knives right after use.
  • Hone with a rod now and then to keep the edge straight.

Frequently Asked Questions

How often should I sharpen my kitchen knives?

It depends on how often you cook. A good sign is when a knife starts to crush a tomato instead of slicing it.

Is a whetstone hard to use?

It takes practice to hold a steady angle, but many people learn the basics in a few sessions.

Can I use one sharpener for every knife?

Often not. Check the maker’s page for which knives and angles it is made for.

Our Verdict

If you are new to sharpening, a guided system is the safest place to start. An electric sharpener suits a busy kitchen, and a whetstone suits someone who wants to learn the craft. Read the maker’s page for your knives first.

Where the facts come from

Product facts come from each maker’s own page and can change, so the label on the item you buy has the final word.